mailtrap and CampaignMonitor Email Deliverability Comparison

mailtrap

CampaignMonitor

In this comparison, the deliverability of mailtrap and CampaignMonitor is compared in detail. All available data, taking the filters into account, is used for the comparison.

Email deliverability

This comparison compares the numbers for sent emails, you can also see in which folder the emails at the email service provider ended up and how many emails were lost on the way. The numbers look better for CampaignMonitor than for mailtrap.

Emails Sent	Emails Inbox	Emails Spam	Emails Lost
75.657 76.027	58.161 58.446	15.843 15.832	1.653 1.749

Email deliverability rates

The following table shows the most important deliverability rates (in percent) for the compared providers. The higher the inbox rate and the lower the spam rate, the better. CampaignMonitor beats mailtrap in this comparison.

Inbox (%)	Spam (%)	Lost (%)
76.87 % 76.88 %	20.94 % 20.82 %	2.18 % 2.30 %

Email deliverability by category

This comparison compares the deliverability taking into account the category or the industry. The deliverability can vary greatly depending on the industry. In this comparison, CampaignMonitor is the clear winner.

Category	Emails Sent	Emails Inbox	Emails Spam	Emails Lost	Inbox (%)	Spam (%)	Lost (%)
Clothing	5903 5866	4509 4511	1275 1230	119 125	76.38 % 76.90 %	21.60 % 20.97 %	2.02 % 2.13 %
Elektronics	5971 5826	4588 4449	1243 1244	140 133	76.84 % 76.36 %	20.82 % 21.35 %	2.34 % 2.28 %
Entertainment	5858 5811	4522 4447	1206 1223	130 141	77.19 % 76.53 %	20.59 % 21.05 %	2.22 % 2.43 %
Cosmetics & Beauty	5731 5885	4404 4564	1194 1183	133 138	76.85 % 77.55 %	20.83 % 20.10 %	2.32 % 2.34 %
Food & Drink	5950 5906	4562 4496	1268 1275	120 135	76.67 % 76.13 %	21.31 % 21.59 %	2.02 % 2.29 %
Home & Garden	5800 5885	4435 4526	1249 1228	116 131	76.47 % 76.91 %	21.53 % 20.87 %	2.00 % 2.23 %
Finance	5718 5612	4583 4485	1005 990	130 137	80.15 % 79.92 %	17.58 % 17.64 %	2.27 % 2.44 %
Health	5773 5810	4626 4689	1020 979	127 142	80.13 % 80.71 %	17.67 % 16.85 %	2.20 % 2.44 %
Pets	5906 5997	4501 4629	1276 1234	129 134	76.21 % 77.19 %	21.61 % 20.58 %	2.18 % 2.23 %
Sport & Fitness	5507 5812	4210 4437	1164 1247	133 128	76.45 % 76.34 %	21.14 % 21.46 %	2.42 % 2.20 %
Job & Career	5898 6083	4429 4528	1353 1415	116 140	75.09 % 74.44 %	22.94 % 23.26 %	1.97 % 2.30 %
Dating	5947 5840	4304 4210	1506 1498	137 132	72.37 % 72.09 %	25.32 % 25.65 %	2.30 % 2.26 %
Other	5695 5694	4488 4475	1084 1086	123 133	78.81 % 78.59 %	19.03 % 19.07 %	2.16 % 2.34 %

Email deliverability by email service provider

Finally, the following table compares the deliverability taking into account the email service provider. Similar to the industry, also the email service provider can affect the email deliverability in both directions — positive or negative. In this comparison, mailtrap is better than CampaignMonitor.

Provider	Emails Sent	Emails Inbox	Emails Spam	Emails Lost	Inbox (%)	Spam (%)	Lost (%)
Gmail	5532 5559	4030 4035	1375 1391	127 133	72.85 % 72.58 %	24.86 % 25.02 %	2.30 % 2.39 %
Outlook Mail	5474 5469	4097 4126	1251 1219	126 124	74.84 % 75.44 %	22.85 % 22.29 %	2.30 % 2.27 %
Yahoo Mail	5396 5322	4115 4054	1168 1145	113 123	76.26 % 76.17 %	21.65 % 21.51 %	2.09 % 2.31 %
AOL Mail	5501 5298	4199 4050	1176 1128	126 120	76.33 % 76.44 %	21.38 % 21.29 %	2.29 % 2.27 %
Mail.com	5440 5401	4213 4196	1111 1086	116 119	77.44 % 77.69 %	20.42 % 20.11 %	2.13 % 2.20 %
Yandex Mail	5434 5389	4130 4085	1180 1185	124 119	76.00 % 75.80 %	21.72 % 21.99 %	2.28 % 2.21 %
GMX Mail	5390 5566	4043 4230	1234 1206	113 130	75.01 % 76.00 %	22.89 % 21.67 %	2.10 % 2.34 %
Zoho Mail	5419 5376	4195 4215	1107 1034	117 127	77.41 % 78.40 %	20.43 % 19.23 %	2.16 % 2.36 %
ProtonMail	5447 5376	4327 4202	1010 1046	110 128	79.44 % 78.16 %	18.54 % 19.46 %	2.02 % 2.38 %
Custom Mail	5294 5399	4252 4299	921 982	121 118	80.32 % 79.63 %	17.40 % 18.19 %	2.29 % 2.19 %
iCloud Mail	5411 5372	4002 3935	1299 1315	110 122	73.96 % 73.25 %	24.01 % 24.48 %	2.03 % 2.27 %
Tuta	5421 5583	4282 4374	1018 1079	121 130	78.99 % 78.34 %	18.78 % 19.33 %	2.23 % 2.33 %
Juno.com	5167 5441	4064 4339	983 976	120 126	78.65 % 79.75 %	19.02 % 17.94 %	2.32 % 2.32 %
Mailfence	5331 5476	4212 4306	1010 1040	109 130	79.01 % 78.63 %	18.95 % 18.99 %	2.04 % 2.37 %

Compare mailtrap with other providers

Compare the email deliverability of mailtrap with other providers.